• 5 Posts
  • 278 Comments
Joined 4 months ago
cake
Cake day: September 4th, 2025

help-circle


  • You are correctly understanding the downside of federation, i.e., instead of just having one “world news” community, you could have multiple. If you subscribe to them all, you could see duplicated posts across them all, or you might miss things if you only subscribe to one, etc… These are the downsides.

    There are upsides to this model too. Let me illustrate with a story in recent history. The mods of  [email protected] were unhappy with some of their admin’s decisions. If this were reddit, they would be shit out of luck, because the admins are the same across all of reddit. Not so in the threadiverse! So the mods decided to hop instances to lemmy.world.

    To make a long story short, now there are at least three “196” communities, with at least two of them thriving: the original 196, which moved back to lemmy.blahaj.zone by popular demand, the [email protected] community, which sprung up to serve all the people who wanted to stay on blahaj when the mods of the original comm left, and [email protected], which was the new home of the 196 mods for a short while, and persisted amongst those who wanted to stay on lemmy.world.

    I feel like I’m describing the migration of the elves in the Simarilion across middle earth. But that is sort of what it was like. Reality imitating fiction and all that.

    Yes, the community divided, but people were able to choose the communities and instances they wanted to participate in. And IMO the memes and shitposts are all the better because of it.

    So tl;dr, yes this splits the audience, but in the end gives communities the freedom to choose which mods and admins they want, instead of getting stuck with unpopular mods or admins.